Here's my next bit of evidence for why I can't go on The Great British Bake-Off. Of course, if you weren't convinced by my chocolate celebration cake, I don't know what else I could tell you.
If you made it through cake week on the first season of Bake-Off, your next challenge was to make your signature biscuit. Of course, being American, I'm much more of a cookie person, and my Giant Sea Salt Chocolate Chip Cookies are definitely my favorite, but there are tons of others that I really love. Somehow, I didn't think any of those would meet the criteria.
Then I remembered my Classic Crunchy Peanut Butter Cookies from an Alton Brown recipe. Their crunchy so seemed more biscuit like, and my love of peanut butter is definitely a defining factor in my life, so if I was going to present something to Paul and Mary, it would probably be these.
This is one of the more popular recipes on my site, so hit that link to get the recipe, as I haven't changed a thing. The only variation is in how long you bake them for. The longer you bake them, the crunchier they'll be, but don't let them get too brown because then they verge on burnt.
I stand behind these cookies. Or biscuits. Whatever. But doubtless, Paul and Mary would find flaws. They have a nice crunch and are not overly sweet. They deliver on the peanut butter flavor, and I can't seem to stop eating them. However, my cookies always come out with some variation in size, shape, and color. I'm not a professional baker, and I never will be.
If you're looking for a simple, classic peanut butter cookie, give these a go. They'll get you through to the technical without any disasters.